There are many mysteries surrounding Europe’s hunter-gatherers, but the rise of farming significantly contributed to their decline, transforming their way of life and reshaping the continent’s cultural and environmental landscape.
Headlines
Why Did Europe’s Hunter-Gatherers Vanish?
The Disappearance of Europe’s Hunter-Gatherers: A Historical Mystery
Europe’s hunter-gatherers were not a single, unified group but rather a diverse array of human populations and cultures, each with its own methods for surviving through hunting and foraging. These early human communities spanned the continent, adapting to a wide range of environments, from the forests of central Europe to the icy reaches of the north.
Hunter-gatherers first arrived in Europe in waves, with some of the earliest groups establishing themselves around 45,000 years ago. However, not all of these early populations managed to thrive. Cosimo Posth, a professor of archeo- and paleogenetics at the University of Tübingen, referred to the initial migration as a “dead branch,” noting that these first settlers did not endure, much like earlier human explorers who ventured into Europe and failed to establish lasting communities.
Yet, the story didn’t end there. Following these early unsuccessful migrations, Europe’s hunter subsequent waves of hunter-gatherers found a foothold in Europe, some of them establishing thriving populations that lasted for millennia. Over time, these groups adapted to their surroundings and developed their unique ways of life, contributing to the mosaic of ancient European cultures.
Posth highlights that modern Europeans carry the genetic legacy of these ancient hunter-gatherers, with around 10% to 15% of contemporary European DNA tracing its roots back to these early populations. Most of Europe’s hunter this genetic inheritance comes from the final wave of hunter-gatherers who spread out from Italy around 14,000 years ago. While much of their way of life has long since vanished, their genetic imprint endures, reminding us that a portion of their heritage still lives on in the people of Europe today.
When farming spread across Europe around 6,000 years ago, it marked a significant turning point in the continent’s history. The hunter-gatherers, who had long lived in relative isolation, found themselves increasingly outnumbered and pushed toward the fringes of Europe. While the two groups lived side by side for a time, their relationship was marked by cultural, genetic, and territorial divides.
Despite the gradual blending of populations, with farmers adopting some hunter-gatherer genetic traits, the hunter-gatherers largely remained genetically distinct. For example, DNA analysis of a 7,000-year-old male hunter-gatherer from Spain revealed that he had blue eyes and dark skin. This phenotype was common among hunter-gatherers across Europe after 14,000 years ago, contrasting with the lighter skin and dark eyes typical of farmers during that time, according to Posth.
As farming communities expanded, they displaced hunter-gatherers from their land. Posth noted that the last of these groups retreated to more remote areas, avoiding direct competition with the growing agricultural populations. The hunter-gatherers’ genetic and cultural presence persisted in these isolated pockets, but their way of life was increasingly marginalized.
However, the interaction between the two groups wasn’t solely one of displacement. Evidence suggests that some hunter-gatherers adopted aspects of farming culture. A notable example is the burial of a 5,800-year-old individual known as Dragsholm Man, found in Denmark. While the man was buried with traditional hunter-gatherer grave goods, his diet mirrored that of early European farmers. This suggests that some hunter-gatherers integrated into farming communities and adopted their ways of life, including their agricultural practices and diets.
Other evidence paints a more violent picture. A 2024 study published in PLOS One detailed the violent ritual sacrifice of a male hunter-gatherer from Scandinavia by a farming community in Denmark, around 5,200 years ago. This sacrifice could indicate a deeper level of conflict between the two groups, though the reasons behind the ritual remain unclear. The hunter-gatherer could have been a captive, an immigrant, or someone who gained equal standing among the farmers.
The rapid spread of farming also brought new challenges for the hunter-gatherers, including exposure to diseases from domesticated animals. Evidence suggests that in Denmark, hunter-gatherer populations were decimated by both the introduction of new pathogens and violent confrontations with farmers. A 2024 Nature study found that hunter-gatherer populations in Denmark were quickly wiped out just a few generations after farmers arrived, signaling a potentially catastrophic shift in the region’s demographic and cultural landscape.
Anders Fischer, an independent archaeologist and author of the studies, argued that the farmers’ expansion was marked by rapid population growth and a “war-like” approach to the native hunter-gatherers. Fischer suggested that the last hunter-gatherers did not voluntarily transition to farming but were instead overwhelmed by the agricultural societies. “Somebody decided on their behalf, and maybe they were wiped out of existence in the same process,” Fischer concluded.
The exact nature of the interaction between Europe’s hunter-gatherers and the incoming farmers remains shrouded in mystery. While some integrated into farming communities, others may have faced violent confrontations or suffered from the diseases brought by the new agricultural societies. What is clear is that the spread of farming irrevocably changed the course of European history, leaving the once-dominant hunter-gatherers a distant memory in the archaeological record.